AP 118 · No. 10 Section IV · Numbers The Almanac · 05

The Almanac

Vietnam

The air war in figures, 1961–1975

The helicopter war, the most heavily bombed countryside in history, and a missile age that arrived before the tactics did. Fourteen years in numbers.

US infantrymen run from a landed UH-1D Huey across a dusty clearing while two more Hueys come in to land behind them.
UH-1D Hueys lift men of the 2nd Battalion, 14th Infantry out of the Filhol Rubber Plantation area north-east of Cu Chi, 1966. The Huey became the emblem of the war: some 7,000 served there, and more than 3,300 were lost.
5,607

helicopters lost in the Vietnam War — about half of the 11,846 that served there

11,846
US helicopters known to have served in Vietnam
3,744
US fixed-wing aircraft lost, all causes
6.7m
tons of air munitions dropped by US bombers and fighter-bombers on Indochina
126,615
B-52 Arc Light sorties, 1965–1973
4,877
helicopter pilots and crew killed

America’s air war in Indochina lasted longer than its part in the Second World War and Korea put together. It began in December 1961, when two Army companies of CH-21 ‘flying bananas’ arrived in Saigon by sea, and it ended with Marine helicopters lifting the last Americans off the embassy roof in April 1975. In between it consumed some 3,700 fixed-wing aircraft and more than 5,000 helicopters, and dropped more than three times the tonnage of bombs the US Army Air Forces dropped in the whole of the Second World War.

The numbers are vast and uneven. Over the North, a small air force of MiG-17s and MiG-21s, backed by thousands of guns and the first big surface-to-air missile system, made American pilots relearn dogfighting. In the South, the helicopter did everything: assault, gunship, ambulance, flying crane. And Australia, Britain’s closest partner in Korea, fought this one alongside the Americans, with Canberras, Caribous and Iroquois.

The helicopter war

About twelve thousand went; nearly half did not come back.

The Vietnam Helicopter Pilots Association has spent decades matching tail numbers to fates. Its 2018 tally lists 11,846 helicopters known to have served and 5,607 losses — combat and accident together. The Bell UH-1 dominates every column: it was the troop carrier (‘slick’), the gunship and the ambulance (‘Dust Off’). Army Hueys alone logged more than 10.7 million flight hours between October 1966 and 1975, probably more combat flying than any other aircraft type in history.

Fig. 1

Helicopters lost, by type

helicopters

= 100 helicopters

  1. Bell UH-1 Iroquois (all variants)of about 7,000 that served
    3,304
  2. Hughes OH-6A Cayuseof 1,422 — a two-in-three loss rate
    964
  3. Bell AH-1G Cobra
    303
  4. Sikorsky UH-34D Seahorse
    211
  5. Boeing Vertol CH-46 Sea Knight
    196
  6. Bell OH-13S Siouxof 275
    173
  7. Boeing Vertol CH-47 Chinook
    155

Losses include accidents. UH-1 total sums the VHPA’s UH-1, -1A, -1B, -1C, -1D, -1E, -1F, -1H, -1M and -1N lines; many UH-1Ds were rebuilt as UH-1Hs, so the two should be read together.

Source Vietnam Helicopter Pilots Association, ‘Helicopter Losses During the Vietnam War’ (updated 31 December 2018)

Fig. 2

Share of all helicopter losses

% of 5,607 helicopters
  • 59% UH-1 Huey (3,304) 59
  • 17% OH-6A Cayuse (964) 17
  • 5% AH-1 Cobra (306) 5
  • 19% All other types (1,033) 19

Source VHPA (2018)

Fig. 3

Helicopter aircrew killed

people
  • Pilots
  • Other crew
  1. In Hueys
    1,1511,231
    2,382
  2. In all other helicopters
    1,0141,481
    2,495

Does not include the passengers — soldiers, casualties, medics — who died aboard. The VHPA has no reliable count for South Vietnamese aircrew.

Source VHPA (2018): 2,165 pilots and 2,712 non-pilot crew killed in all; 1,151 pilots and 1,231 crew in Hueys

US infantrymen run from a landed UH-1D Huey across a dusty clearing while two more Hueys come in to land behind them.
UH-1D Hueys lift men of the 2nd Battalion, 14th Infantry out of the Filhol Rubber Plantation area north-east of Cu Chi, 1966. The Huey became the emblem of the war: some 7,000 served there, and more than 3,300 were lost.
  1. UH-1D ‘slick’ on the ground, skids down, rotor still turning
  2. Door gunner’s M60 machine gun
  3. The next Huey coming in to land
  4. More of the lift in the distance — air assaults came in waves
SFC James K. F. Dung, US Army, Public domain · source

Tonnage

More than three Second World Wars’ worth, mostly on the country being defended.

Fig. 4

US bombs in three wars

tons
  1. Indochina, 1962–1973 (bombers and fighter-bombers)
    6,715,500
  2. Second World War, US Army Air Forces, all theatres
    2,057,244
  3. Korea, 1950–1953
    635,000

Aircraft of all kinds, including helicopters and gunships, expended about 8 million tons in Indochina. Figures are approximate and the definitions differ slightly between wars.

Source Moïse, Historical Dictionary of the Vietnam War (2001); USAAF Statistical Digest, World War II (1945); Kiernan & Owen (2015)

Fig. 5

Where the bombs fell, 1962–1973

tons
  1. South Vietnam (1962–73)
    3,203,000
  2. Laos (1964–73)
    2,093,300
  3. North Vietnam (1964–73)
    880,108
  4. Cambodia (1969–73)later analysis of US Air Force records suggests far more
    539,129

Owen and Kiernan’s 2006 analysis of the Air Force database put the Cambodia total at 2,756,941 tons from 1965 to 1973. South Vietnam — the ally — was by a wide margin the most heavily bombed country in history; Laos is second.

Source Moïse, Historical Dictionary of the Vietnam War (2001), from US Air Force figures

Fig. 6

US military personnel in Vietnam, end of each year

people
US military personnel in Vietnam, end of each year
YearUS personnel in South Vietnam
19613200
196211300
196316300
196423300
1965184300
1966385300
1967485600
1968536100
1969475200
1970334600
1971156800
197224200
197350

The air war outlasted the ground war: in 1972, with fewer than 25,000 Americans left in the South, US aircraft flew the heaviest bombing campaign since 1968.

Source US Department of Defense, year-end strength figures

Four camouflaged F-105D Thunderchiefs releasing bombs in formation above hazy countryside.
F-105D Thunderchiefs of the 34th Tactical Fighter Squadron bombing on radar cues, c.1966–68. The F-105 carried most of Rolling Thunder’s weight north — and lost 382 aircraft doing it.US Air Force, Public domain · source

Over the North

MiGs, missiles and the school that rewrote the exchange ratio.

Rolling Thunder, the bombing of North Vietnam from March 1965 to November 1968, cost 922 American aircraft. Most fell to anti-aircraft guns; the SA-2 missile forced bombers down into the guns’ range, and the MiGs picked their moments. The Phantom had been designed to kill bombers with radar-guided missiles at long range, and early F-4s carried no gun. Against small, agile MiG-17s and MiG-21s flown by pilots under close ground control, the results were sobering. The US Navy studied why — the Ault report — and in March 1969 founded the Fighter Weapons School, Top Gun. The Air Force already had a Fighter Weapons School at Nellis, but did not overhaul its air-combat training until after the war, with Red Flag in 1975.

Fig. 7

Air-to-air exchange ratios: Korea to Vietnam

enemy aircraft claimed per own aircraft lost in air combat
  1. Korea: Sabre pilots’ claims792 claimed for 78 lost
    10
  2. Korea: Sabre, recent research (RAND)
    1.8
  3. Vietnam: US Navy, before Top Gun
    2.4
  4. Vietnam: US Air Force, whole war137 claimed for 67 lost to MiGs
    2
  5. Vietnam: US Navy, after Top Gun
    13

US claims set against US-acknowledged losses. North Vietnamese records admit roughly 150 aircraft lost in all; the Vietnamese air force claimed far more American aircraft than the US acknowledges.

Source Winnefeld, ‘Topgun: Getting it Right’, US Naval Institute Proceedings (1986); Michel, Clashes (1997); RAND (2008)

Fig. 8

Phantom against MiG-21

McDonnell Douglas F-4J Phantom II

Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-21MF

  • 18 mLength16 m
  • 12 mWingspan7.2 m
  • 13,757 kgEmpty weight5,350 kg
  • 28,030 kgMax take-off weight9,800 kg
  • 2Crew1

Verdict The Phantom was twice the MiG-21’s size and had more than twice its thrust, radar to see a long way and eight missiles. The MiG was small, hard to spot, quick to accelerate and carried an internal cannon. Fought at close quarters under strict rules of engagement that often required visual identification first, the Phantom’s advantages shrank.

Source National Museum of the USAF; Gordon & Komissarov, Mikoyan MiG-21 (2008); figures vary by sub-type

Fig. 9

Phantoms lost in Southeast Asia, by service

aircraft

= 20 aircraft

  1. US Air Force (F-4 and RF-4)
    445
  2. US Navy
    138
  3. US Marine Corps
    95

All causes. The Phantom lost more aircraft in Vietnam than any other fixed-wing type — partly because there were so many of them.

Source Hobson, Vietnam Air Losses (2001), as tabulated by Wikipedia, Aircraft losses of the Vietnam War

Fig. 10

US fixed-wing losses by type, all services, all causes

aircraft
  1. F-4 Phantom II
    678
  2. O-1 Bird Dog
    476
  3. F-105 Thunderchief
    382
  4. A-4 Skyhawk
    363
  5. A-1 Skyraider
    256
  6. F-100 Super Sabre
    243
  7. OV-10 Bronco
    80
  8. C-130 HerculesUSAF only; the Marines lost four more KC-130s
    55
  9. B-52 Stratofortress
    31

Type totals combine the services and may differ slightly from other counts. Of the 2,251 aircraft the USAF lost, 1,737 fell to hostile action and 514 to accidents.

Source Hobson, Vietnam Air Losses (2001), as tabulated by Wikipedia, Aircraft losses of the Vietnam War

922US aircraft lost in Rolling Thunder, 1965–68
205US fixed-wing aircraft lost to SAMs, by US records (206 with one helicopter)
~4%of SA-2s fired that hit, by a 1966 CIA estimate
2,750SA-2s fired during Linebacker I, 1972, for 46 aircraft downed
7MiG-21s claimed in Operation Bolo, 2 January 1967, for no loss
5US aces of the war: two Navy, three Air Force

Source Schlight and Hobson via Wikipedia (Rolling Thunder); CIA memorandum, 1966; Hobson’s loss database (vietnamairlosses.com) for Linebacker I; USAF and USN

Overhead view of a US Navy F-4J Phantom of VF-96, number 100 and serial 5800, marked USS Constellation, flying above broken cloud with missiles on an underwing pylon.
F-4J BuNo 155800, ‘Showtime 100’ of VF-96 from USS Constellation. In this aircraft on 10 May 1972 Lt Randy Cunningham and Lt (jg) William Driscoll shot down three MiG-17s to become the first American aces of the war; a SAM then hit them on the way home, and both were rescued from the sea.
  1. VF-96 ‘Fighting Falcons’, USS Constellation
  2. Radar nose — the F-4J carried no gun
  3. Victory stars painted below the cockpit
  4. Air-to-air missiles on the inboard wing pylon
US Navy, Public domain · source

Arc Light and Linebacker

The strategic bomber in a war without strategic targets — until the last eleven nights.

The first B-52 strike of the war, on 18 June 1965, went badly: two bombers collided on the way in and eight men died. Arc Light went on for eight years. Flying from Guam, Okinawa and U-Tapao in Thailand, B-52s flew 126,615 sorties, most of them against jungle bases in the South and supply routes in Laos and Cambodia, unheard until the bombs landed. In December 1972 they were finally sent against Hanoi and Haiphong. Linebacker II lasted eleven nights, and fifteen B-52s were shot down — all by SA-2 missiles.

Fig. 11

Linebacker II, 18–29 December 1972

aircraft

= 25 aircraft

  1. B-52 sorties
    729
  2. B-52s shot downone more was lost in some counts
    15
  3. Other US aircraft lostfigures of 11 to 13 are given
    12

Some 20,000 tons of bombs in eleven nights. US aircrew losses were 43 killed and 49 captured; at least 1,624 civilians were killed in Hanoi and Haiphong.

Source USAF; McCarthy & Allison, Linebacker II: A View from the Rock (1979); Wikipedia, Operation Linebacker II

A B-52D in black and camouflage paint releasing a long vertical stream of bombs over cloud.
B-52D 55-0100 drops its load over Vietnam. The ‘Big Belly’ D could carry 108 bombs; a cell of three laid a box of craters roughly a mile long.
  1. Tail serial 0-50100: B-52D 55-0100
  2. Open bomb bay — the D model was modified to carry up to 84 bombs inside
  3. More bombs falling from the underwing racks
  4. Black undersides for night bombing, camouflage above
US Air Force, Public domain · source
Fig. 12

Fourteen years in the air

  1. The first US Army helicopter units — CH-21 Shawnees — arrive in Saigon.

  2. Gulf of Tonkin incident; first US air strikes on the North, and the first US airman captured.

  3. Rolling Thunder begins on 2 March.

  4. First Arc Light B-52 raid, 18 June.

  5. An SA-2 destroys a USAF F-4C on 24 July: the first US aircraft lost to a surface-to-air missile.

  6. Operation Bolo: F-4s posing as F-105s claim seven MiG-21s on 2 January.

  7. No. 2 Squadron RAAF begins Canberra operations from Phan Rang.

  8. Rolling Thunder ends on 1 November after 922 aircraft lost.

  9. US Navy Fighter Weapons School — Top Gun — opens at NAS Miramar.

  10. Cunningham and Driscoll become the first US aces of the war, 10 May, as Linebacker I begins.

  11. Linebacker II, 18–29 December: 729 B-52 sorties, 15 B-52s lost.

  12. US bombing of Cambodia ends on 15 August; the last Arc Light sortie is flown.

  13. Operation Frequent Wind: helicopters evacuate Saigon, 29–30 April.

Source Wikipedia (campaign articles); Australian War Memorial; Grossnick & Evans, United States Naval Aviation 1910–2010

Australia’s air war

Wallaby Airlines, the Bushrangers and the Magpies.

Australia sent three RAAF squadrons to Vietnam. No. 35 Squadron’s Caribous — ‘Wallaby Airlines’ — arrived first, in August 1964, and flew into strips too short for anything bigger. No. 9 Squadron’s Iroquois carried the Australian Task Force at Nui Dat, and from 1969 flew its own ‘Bushranger’ gunships. No. 2 Squadron, the ‘Magpies’, flew Canberra B.20 bombers from Phan Rang as part of a USAF wing; it flew only about 5 per cent of the wing’s missions but was credited with 16 per cent of its bomb damage, bombing at low level with great accuracy. Its two lost Canberras were the only Australian jet losses of the war.

Fig. 13

Australian air units in the Vietnam War

No. 35 Squadron (RAAF Transport Flight Vietnam)RAAFDHC-4 CaribouVung Tau19641972About 80,000 sorties; 677,000–700,000 passengers carried
No. 9 SquadronRAAFUH-1B, UH-1H IroquoisVung Tau19661971Troop lift, casualty evacuation and ‘Bushranger’ gunships
No. 2 SquadronRAAFCanberra B.20Phan Rang1967197176,389 bombs dropped; two aircraft lost
RAN Helicopter Flight VietnamRANUH-1 IroquoisBearcat19671971Flew with the US Army’s 135th Assault Helicopter Company
161 (Independent) Reconnaissance FlightAustralian ArmyCessna 180, Bell 47G Sioux, Pilatus PorterNui Dat19651971Reconnaissance and liaison for the Task Force
RAAF forward air controllersRAAFO-1 Bird Dog, OV-10 Broncowith USAF units19661971Pilots attached individually to USAF FAC squadrons
No. 79 SquadronRAAFCAC SabreUbon, Thailand19621968Air defence of Thailand; never in combat
RAAF aircraft lost in Vietnam: three Caribous (one to enemy fire, two in accidents), two Canberras and six Iroquois, by the most-cited count. Sortie and passenger figures vary between sources.

Source Australian War Memorial; DVA Anzac Portal; RAAF Association; Air Force History and Heritage Branch, RAAF helicopter operations in Vietnam

Australian soldiers with packs and rifles run across a gravel pad towards two olive-drab RAAF Iroquois helicopters.
Men of B Company, 2nd Battalion Royal Australian Regiment, run to board No. 9 Squadron RAAF Iroquois at Nui Dat.PFC Laszlo Kondor, US Army, Public domain · source
Australian infantrymen with packs stand on a grass strip watching a twin-engined Caribou come in to land.
Soldiers of 5RAR wait as a No. 35 Squadron Caribou comes in to collect them, October 1969. ‘Wallaby Airlines’ flew about 80,000 sorties in Vietnam.Christopher John Bellis, Australian War Memorial (BEL/69/0741/VN), Public domain (PD-Australia) · source
Aerial view of rows of aircraft revetments at Phan Rang air base, with runways and hills beyond.
Phan Rang air base, July 1967: rows of revetments shared by USAF wings and No. 2 Squadron RAAF’s Canberras.US National Archives (342-KKE-28349), Public domain · source
Fig. 14

The Vietnam war at one scale

drawn to one scale
  1. Canberra B.20 (No. 2 Sqn RAAF) — the USAF flew the licence-built Martin B-57, side view Canberra B.20 (No. 2 Sqn RAAF) — the USAF flew the licence-built Martin B-57 20.0 m
  2. Douglas AC-47D ‘Spooky’ gunship, side view Douglas AC-47D ‘Spooky’ gunship 19.7 m
  3. UH-1H Huey, side view UH-1H Huey 17.4 m
  4. CH-47 Chinook, side view CH-47 Chinook 15.5 m
  5. HH-43 Huskie, side view HH-43 Huskie 7.7 m
  6. OH-13 Sioux, side view OH-13 Sioux 9.6 m
  7. F-100 Super Sabre, side view F-100 Super Sabre 16.5 m
  8. F-111, side view F-111 22.4 m
  9. MiG-21, side view MiG-21 14.9 m
  10. C-130 Hercules, side view C-130 Hercules 34.4 m
Fig. 15

Parked together: a Vietnam airfield

live 3D, true scale
  • F-4 Phantom II 17.6 m long, 11.7 m span
  • Canberra B.20 20.0 m long, 19.5 m span
  • AC-47 Spooky 19.7 m long, 29.0 m span
  • UH-1H Huey 17.4 m long, 14.6 m rotor
  • CH-47 Chinook 15.5 m long, 18.3 m rotor
  • HH-43 Huskie 7.7 m long, 14.3 m rotor
  • OH-13 Sioux 9.6 m long, 11.3 m rotor
  • F-100 Super Sabre 16.5 m long, 11.8 m span
  • F-111 22.4 m long, 19.2 m span
  • MiG-21 14.9 m long, 7.2 m span
  • C-130 Hercules 34.4 m long, 40.4 m span
A camouflaged Douglas AC-47D gunship, tail code EN and number 593, flying over a coastline with mountains behind.
AC-47D 44-76593 of the 4th Special Operations Squadron in flight, 1968: a wartime Dakota turned into a gunship.
  1. Open cargo door on the left side — Spooky’s guns all fired to port
  2. Cabin windows, some removed for minigun barrels
  3. Tail code EN, 4th Special Operations Squadron
  4. Two Pratt & Whitney Twin Wasps, as on any Dakota
US Air Force, Public domain · source
Time-exposure photograph at night of curving red tracer streams from an AC-47 gunship above the lit buildings of Saigon.
A time exposure of an AC-47 ‘Spooky’ firing over the outskirts of Saigon during the 1968 fighting. Each streak is the trace of thousands of rounds from the gunship’s side-firing miniguns.US Air Force, Public domain · source

They can’t even bomb an outhouse without my approval.

Attributed to President Lyndon B. Johnson, on his control of Rolling Thunder targets

Where to see them

Vietnam-era types in British museums.

Fig. 16

Where to see Vietnam War types in Britain

in British museums

Sources

  1. Vietnam Helicopter Pilots Association, ‘Helicopter Losses During the Vietnam War’ (Gary Roush, updated 31 December 2018)
  2. Chris Hobson, Vietnam Air Losses: USAF, Navy and Marine Corps Fixed-Wing Aircraft Losses in Southeast Asia 1961–1973 (Midland, 2001)
  3. Wikipedia, Aircraft losses of the Vietnam War (tabulating Hobson and VHPA)
  4. Edwin E. Moïse, Historical Dictionary of the Vietnam War (Scarecrow Press, 2001) — air war tonnage figures
  5. Taylor Owen and Ben Kiernan, ‘Bombs over Cambodia’, The Walrus (2006); Kiernan & Owen, ‘Making More Enemies than We Kill?’, The Asia-Pacific Journal (2015)
  6. Army Air Forces Statistical Digest, World War II (1945)
  7. Marshall L. Michel III, Clashes: Air Combat over North Vietnam 1965–1972 (Naval Institute Press, 1997)
  8. James A. Winnefeld, ‘Topgun: Getting it Right’, US Naval Institute Proceedings 112/10 (1986)
  9. Wikipedia, United States Navy Strike Fighter Tactics Instructor program
  10. Wikipedia, Operation Rolling Thunder
  11. Wikipedia, Operation Linebacker II
  12. National Museum of the United States Air Force, ‘Arc Light’ fact sheet
  13. Steven J. Zaloga, Red SAM: The SA-2 Guideline Anti-Aircraft Missile (Osprey, 2007)
  14. Wikipedia, List of U.S. aircraft losses to missiles during the Vietnam War
  15. DVA Anzac Portal, No 35 Squadron RAAF during the Vietnam War
  16. DVA Anzac Portal, No 9 Squadron RAAF during the Vietnam War
  17. RAAF Association, ‘2 Sqn Canberras in Vietnam’
  18. Air Force History and Heritage Branch, RAAF in the Vietnam War: RAAF helicopter operations in Vietnam

Photographs

  • UH-1D Hueys lift men of the 2nd Battalion, 14th Infantry out of the Filhol Rubbe — SFC James K. F. Dung, US Army, Public domain · source
  • F-105D Thunderchiefs of the 34th Tactical Fighter Squadron bombing on radar cues — US Air Force, Public domain · source
  • F-4J BuNo 155800, ‘Showtime 100’ of VF-96 from USS Constellation. In this aircra — US Navy, Public domain · source
  • B-52D 55-0100 drops its load over Vietnam. The ‘Big Belly’ D could carry 108 bom — US Air Force, Public domain · source
  • Men of B Company, 2nd Battalion Royal Australian Regiment, run to board No. 9 Sq — PFC Laszlo Kondor, US Army, Public domain · source
  • Soldiers of 5RAR wait as a No. 35 Squadron Caribou comes in to collect them, Oct — Christopher John Bellis, Australian War Memorial (BEL/69/0741/VN), Public domain (PD-Australia) · source
  • Phan Rang air base, July 1967: rows of revetments shared by USAF wings and No. 2 — US National Archives (342-KKE-28349), Public domain · source
  • AC-47D 44-76593 of the 4th Special Operations Squadron in flight, 1968: a wartim — US Air Force, Public domain · source
  • A time exposure of an AC-47 ‘Spooky’ firing over the outskirts of Saigon during — US Air Force, Public domain · source

Figures are drawn from the sources above; where they disagree the most widely cited figure is used and the range is given in the notes. Side profiles and 3D models are the gazetteer’s own procedural models, drawn to scale from published dimensions. Spotted an error? Tell us.